Premier Listing
Shadow Canyon’s Elk Paradise
$799,000
100 Acres
Fence Lake, New Mexico, 87315
Experience the ultimate turnkey (several pieces of equipment include) hunting retreat—ready for you to enjoy from day one! This exceptional property f...
Fence Lake, NM Land & Properties for Sale
5 Results
Premier Listing
Mujeres 45 Hunting Camp
$112,500
45 Acres
Fence Lake, New Mexico, 87315
Escape to your own 45-acre retreat! This vacant land features rolling slopes, striking rock outcroppings, and a beautiful mix of pinon pine and junipe...
Elk Ridge Ranch
$975,000
626.11 Acres
Fence Lake, New Mexico, 87513
Set on ±626.11 acres in western New Mexico’s Unit 12, Elk Ridge Ranch offers a mix of productive grasslands, piñon-juniper ridges, and rugged sandston...
Rancho Vista
$625,000
256.79 Acres
Fence Lake, New Mexico, 87513
Positioned just east of Elk Ridge, this ±256-acre ranch offers classic New Mexico mesa country with sweeping views, strong wildlife presence, and rema...
Fence Lake 161 Acres Hunting Property with Extra Large Barn
$275,000
161 Acres
Fence Lake, New Mexico, 87315
Please consider our 161-acre off-grid hunting Property off of Moreno Hill Rd 35A, west of Fence Lake, approximately 5 to 6 miles. This property should...
Nearby Properties You May Like
Catron County 198
$206,910
197.68 Acres
Quemado, New Mexico, 87829
Price recently reduced by over $10,000 Wide open spaces, is the way to describe this 197.68 +/- acre parcel, with gentle rolling terrain, dotted scatt...
Tierra Verde Lot 66
$33,395
6.25 Acres
Grants, New Mexico, 87020
Escape to the beauty of western New Mexico with this 6.25-acre parcel located in Tierra Verde Ranchettes. Featuring mostly level terrain and a healthy...
Premier Listing
Black Mountain Retreat
$639,000
50 Acres
Pie Town, New Mexico, 87827
Welcome to this unique property just outside of Pie Town, NM, a hidden gem that has served as both an outfitter operation and a tranquil retreat. Nest...
Premier Listing
Lookout Mountain Ranch
$11,000,000
3,000 Acres
Grants, New Mexico, 87020
Over 3,000 deeded acres nearly surrounded by National Forest Trophy elk hunting with six landowner bull elk tags Mule deer, turkey, & bear with over t...
Agua Fria Retreat
$1,149,950
40.95 Acres
Bluewater, New Mexico, 87005
Owner financing is NOW available for Agua Fria Retreat with 30% down at 4% interest over 15 years, now priced more than $215,000 below its original $1...
Hines Ranch Retreat
$3,950,000
96 Acres
Apache Creek, New Mexico, 87820
The Hines Ranch Retreat is a magical property in western New Mexico. Sleeping approximately 40 (4 homes and 4 cabins), with a full commercial diner, s...
Tularosa Springs Farm & Ranch - Aragon, NM
$2,200,000
124 Acres
Aragon, New Mexico, 87820
Summary: This 124 acre ranch is located in the sought-after NM Big Elk Hunting Unit 16D and borders National Forest (see below). River runs through it...
Buying land in Fence Lake, NM
Fence Lake has 5 land listings on the market, a small part of Cibola County's 8. Most carry the hunting land and recreational land tags (5 each), with acreage (4) also listed. Parcels run from 45 to 626 acres; the typical parcel is 161 acres.
Prices start at $112,500 and top out at $975,000; the typical asking price is $625,000. Per acre, Fence Lake land averages about $2,344. The largest parcel, 626 acres, asks $975,000. One of the listings is an auction.
Fence Lake land listings by type
| Type | Listings | Median price | Average price per acre | Acreage range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hunting Land | 5 | $625,000 | $2,344 | 45 to 626 |
| Recreational Land | 5 | $625,000 | $2,344 | 45 to 626 |
| Acreage | 4 | $537,000 | $2,319 | 45 to 626 |
| Mountain Land | 4 | $712,000 | $2,443 | 45 to 626 |
| Ranch | 4 | $712,000 | $2,338 | 100 to 626 |
| Equestrian Property | 3 | $799,000 | $2,441 | 100 to 626 |
| Cattle Ranch | 2 | $800,000 | $1,812 | 257 to 626 |
| Timberland | 2 | $800,000 | $1,812 | 257 to 626 |
- Listings
- 5
- Share of Cibola County
- 13%
- Typical parcel
- 161 acres
- Typical asking price
- $625,000
- Average per acre
- $2,344
- Parcel range
- 45 to 626 acres
Around Fence Lake
Cibola County has 8 listings in all.